

Forest 1 Barnsley 0
By: Tim | December 4th, 2008Although that axe is still hovering dangerously above Calderwood’s head, Saturday’s defeat of Barnsley has at least granted him a stay of execution. We’ll have to wait and see how long for, depending on the next few results, but CC was in a bullish mood after the game; he challenged the players to prove their worth and then went on to claim that the speculation surrounding his position has not affected him: ‘You might find it bizarre or think I’m naïve, but what has happened this week hasn’t really concerned me’.
Frankly I do find it a little bizarre, but hey, if he’s concentrating on the football then all the better for us. At least the players are behind him, and although there was a period when we seemed to be hanging on against the Tykes, there are some plus points to be taken from this match. Earnshaw played close to 90 minutes for starters, and, after being recalled from his loan spell at Rushden & Diamonds, it was good to see Brendan Moloney deputise well at right back.
While Camp has had a few sketchy moments for us, particularly against Doncaster, he once again showed us why he notched up 5 caps playing for England Under-21s, the most notable of his saves being Anderson De Silva’s free-kick late in the game. Calderwood was quick to praise him. Tyson and Garner seem to have struck up an understanding too, the former using his pace to good effect on the left when he provided the cross for Garner’s goal. Pity, then, that Tyson picked up his fifth yellow card of the season – he’s facing a one-match suspension which means he’ll miss out on Saturday’s trip to Coventry.
In other, more positive news, Julian Bennett is on the mend after getting through 90 minutes in a reserve match. Calderwood is currently weighing up whether or not to include him in the squad for Saturday. The reserves have recently been praised by none other than Arsene Wenger, too, after a 2-0 defeat to Arsenal’s second-string in a behind-closed-doors friendly last week. Wenger told the reserve team coach (John Pemberton) that the way we play is ‘how he believes football should be played’, which is surely good to hear.
Lastly, we’ve drawn Manchester City in the third-round of the FA Cup. An exciting prospect, considering everything that is currently happening at Eastlands, although given Calderwood’s reputation for not being bothered by cup matches this tie has ‘defeat’ written all over it. Expect a banal story on the Forest website about how he’d rather concentrate on survival instead of a Cup-run. Then again, the game is due to be played on the 3rd of January, so he might not be in charge anyway.
![]() |
Bet on Nottingham Forest Games Discount Travel to Nottingham Nottingham Forest Scores |
Subscribe
|
Print
|
Share
![]() |
Comments
-



I was reading an article that says Calderwood wants to use a diamond formation so he can have all 3 (Earnshaw, Garner, and Tyson) Strikers on the pitch. Obviously with Tyson’s suspension this week that isn’t a possibility. Tim what do you think about a formation like this or would you prefer to see something a little more defence oriented? I for one think our goals for, while not being the greatest, isn’t the problem…its keeping them out. But I must say that most of my insight comes from reading match reports as opposed to actually seeing the game; a report can only tell me so much.
Posted from
Canada

-



Personally I’m not a fan of the 4-3-3, it leaves us short in midfield and open to attack. If we had the defence to back it up, or a brilliant Makelele style defensive-midfielder, then yeah, the diamond would be great, but we don’t.
I can see what he is trying to do, and Tyson’s pace is definitely an asset, but Calderwood’s tried 4-3-3 a few times this season, and every time he does he rightly gets hammered by the fans. Particularly after the Wolves result. I prefer an orthodox 4-4-2 myself, traditional but with the players we’ve got at the moment it’s a balanced formation for us.
Posted from
United States

-



Yeah, I am in the same boat. What are your thoughts on Roy Keane’s departure from Sunderland? Is there even a slight chance he could take over from Calderwood?
Posted from
Canada

-



His departure was probably slightly premature, they are in the relegation zone but that’s only on goal difference, and it’s quite tight in the Prem at the moment, had he been able to string a few wins together then they could have been fighting for a Uefa Cup spot.
You could question his managerial skills though, he does a hell of a lot of rotation and some of his purchases aren’t exactly top-drawer. He’s a reclusive character too, apparently he doesn’t take training sessions – this and the rotation policy meant he lost the dressing room at Sunderland. All told, Forest legend though he is, I don’t really want to see him at the City Ground. I doubt he’d take it even if he was offered it, so the chances are slim basically!
Posted from
United States

-



Fair enough. Still a bit of a Forest newbie over here so I am not sure what the sentiments are towards a guy like Roy Keane. I did read that when Keane was at Forest Brian Clough was good enough to let him go back to Ireland to visit his family every so often, so your reclusive comment doesn’t actually surprise me all that much.
Posted from
United States

-



Didn’t know that, this is the same Clough that once chinned Keane for a mis-placed backpass though! To be honest I don’t really know what the general sentiment on Keane is, I think parts of the older generation might not have forgiven him for going to Man United, but then footie fans can be fickle, they might welcome him back. Personally I think it would be a bad move anyway.
One things for sure, there’s a large section of fans saying no to Billy Davies as manager…
Posted from
United States

-



I can imagine why!
Decent result on the weekend. Would have been nice to see Plymouth hold Doncaster to get us up to 22nd. 3 points back of Watford to safety. Tuesday will be a big one!
Posted from
Canada

Comments are closed













